Here is the sentiment overview for this Easter shortened trading week:
This week’s sentiment survey from the American Association of Individual Investors shows 44% bears and 36% bulls. That’s a 7 percentage point change from last week for both camps (a decrease for bulls and an increase for bears).
This is a welcome development because although the market (S&P 500) closed the week higher than it started, sentiment is actually less hopeful than it was. This is just one glimmer of contrarian sentiment and it is a shallow change (at only 7%) but still it is valid. At this point, we’ll take what we can.
In contrast, the survey of newsletter editors conducted by ChartCraft shows little change from last week. Tuesday’s results show 36% bulls and 37.1% bears - putting the two sides equally at odds. In early March, we saw a somewhat polarized sentiment. But as the rally unfolded, both the optimists and pessimists have been slowly approaching each other.
The 25% rally this past month has brought out the experts. And for the most part they are now back to their talking points. Take for example, Howard Ruff. He’s decidedly bearish as usual and saying that the recent move is just a bear market rally. He’s looking for hyperinflation and a “toxic” stock market for the foreseeable future.
On the other hand, the spasmodic Jim Cramer has declared the “the depression is over”. Never mind that it was just a few months ago that he asked people to leave the market for the next 5 years. And even shorter still when he promised by a gentleman’s handshake that Mad Money will feature a more rational host. The worst is over! And it is time to become a roaring bull (again). Cue the soundboard. Increase the props department’s budget!
The lesson here is to recognize the inherent bias in every source and to recalibrate what they say based on that. There are very, very few who are as easily bears as bulls and rather than swayed by a bias, rely on evidence based market analysis.
Two weeks ago, I mentioned in a similar sentiment overview that the itchy triggered Rydex traders have stampeded to the bull’s side. To put it bluntly, these traders are too excited for their own good and are positioned as they were at previous tops.
The ISEE sentiment index, which measures retail option traders, showed a consistent level of optimism all throughout this shortened trading week. Although never reaching spike highs (of 200+), the call-put ratio was noteworthy for the elevated plateau it reached. Here are ratios for the equity only ISE sentiment:
- Monday — 169
- Tuesday — 170
- Wednesday — 167
- Thursday — 174
The last time the ISE index spent 4 consecutive days above 167 was late last year, just as the S&P 500 reached a peak in early January 2009.
Follow the link for an update on the CBOE put call ratio (equity only).
The SEC is putting out feelers for a change to the rules governing a short sale. It wasn’t that long ago that the uptick rule was removed but there is now a real possibility that either it will be reinstated or some similar protocols will be put in place. From a sentiment perspective, the important thing is what people think about the change. If enough think that it will be a positive, it will be, irrespective of whether it truly is. This is the crazy, self-fulfilling effect that the market can have on itself - in the short term. In the long term, reality always reasserts itself like a wave of ice cold water.
Persevering readers will remember that we’ve looked at market breadth a number of ways this week. Here’s another: the simple 25 day moving average of the Nasdaq daily advance decline statistics.
Clearly, we are seeing an extreme in market breadth, no matter what your choice of yardstick. And such extremes usual mark the exhaustion point of rallies, leaving the S&P 500 wheezing and panting for breath. If the market doesn’t retrace, then it goes sideways to catch its breadth (couldn’t resist).
The same can be seen in previous bear market rallies. For example, late January 2001 and May 2001 (not shown in the chart) were both times when the Nasdaq 25 day moving average of the advance decline reached extremes and both times also coincide with the top for a bear market rally.
The only time that the market shrugs off such extreme exertions is under abnormal market conditions. For example, as you can see in the chart above, in the summer of 2003, as the market roared out of the depth of the bear market, it hardly paused when met with a similar extreme breadth.
So the question is, which state is the market in now? normal (bear market rally)? or abnormal (a young bull market)? No one knows really but the clue will be in how much the market gives back - if any - as it works off this extreme breadth situation.
Enjoyed this? Don't miss the next one, grab the feed or