It seems you have JavaScript disabled.

Ummm.. Yeah... I'm going to have to ask you to turn Javascript back on... Yeah... Thanks.

Sentiment Overview: Week Of January 25th, 2008 at Trader’s Narrative

Alright, here is the belated sentiment overview for the past week:

Sentiment Surveys
There was hardly a change in the LowRisk numbers with still about 57% bearish and only 32% bullish. The AAII bears increased to 59% while the bulls remained almost constant at 25%. So the retail investors are still very frightened - which is good from a contrarian perspective.

Although the bears increased and the bulls decreased, the Investor’s Intelligence survey of newsletter writers continues to be the “odd man out” because it is still showing more bullish sentiment than bearish (41.6% vs. 31.5%).

This dichotomy of sentiment between the newsletter writers and retail investors is rare but it has occurred before. Usually we can discount it because of the subjective method that II uses to come up with the results. But we have confirmation from the Hulbert newsletter sentiment indicators. So for whatever reason, newsletters have not thrown in the towel, despite the +20% market decline. This could be a fly in the ointment, unless we see them capitulate soon.

ISEE Index
The CBOE equity only put call ratio spent several days above or at the 1.0 threshold (click for graph). With the short term market recovery, it has backed off to 0.67 - a neutral reading.

I prefer the ISEE Sentiment Index to the traditional CBOE put call ratio because it provides a clearer picture of the “dumb money”. By the way, when I use a term like that, I hope I don’t offend anyone. It’s just a word that describes a theoretical group of market participants out there.

Here’s a chart of the ISEE Index going back to early 2007:
isee index Jan 2008

The previous times it has come down as low as it did recently were very good times to be a buyer: early March 2007, August 2007 and late November 2007. Although we’ve recovered from those lows, as long as the ISEE doesn’t go too high too fast (above 150), we have the stage set for a continued recovery.

Magazine Covers
negative economist cover jan 26 2008 its rough out thereOn the left, is the most recent Economist magazine cover page. The gloomy picture of a man bracing himself against a blustery storm with the superimposed red line showing the dropping stock market is a great negative image. I haven’t had a chance to read the accompanying article but the fact that they went along with this image and the title: “It’s rough out there” gives us all we really need.

barrons jan 28 2008 whack that bearTo contrast that, Barron’s cover page is a bit more nuanced. Although it shows a bear captaining the ship of the market, a bull is about to “whack” it from behind with a baseball bat (ala Deniro). No doubt, this is a bullish cover and from a strict contrarian point of view, problematic.

But you have to remember that Barron’s is a specialized publication, written for and read by the financially literate. They were the ones that had many prescient covers, including the infamous “Dot Bomb” cover which presaged the bursting of the internet bubble. So I’m not in a hurry to see this as a bad omen.

Enjoyed this? Don't miss the next one, grab the feed  or 

                               subscribe through email:  

3 Responses to “Sentiment Overview: Week Of January 25th, 2008”  

  1. 1 jeff

    The covers of “The Economist” have been a good indicator a few different time. When they did their “Shrinking Dollar” cover, the dollar rallied. There’s been a few more covers over the past 25 years that have been good indicators.


  1. 1 Monday links: quant quakes « Abnormal Returns
  2. 2 Long Term Composite Indicator Hits Extreme - Investors Intelligence

Leave a Reply