It seems you have JavaScript disabled.

Ummm.. Yeah... I'm going to have to ask you to turn Javascript back on... Yeah... Thanks.

Sentiment Overview: Week Of November 13th, 2009 at Trader’s Narrative

This week’s sentiment run-down has a lot of cross currents so be careful:

After last week’s sudden stampede to an extremely gloomy stance, the weekly survey of retail investors by the American Association of Individual Investors is showing a dramatic realignment to perfectly neutral. The bears and bulls both stand at 39% after a -/+17% percentage point change.

Investors Intelligence
The percentage of stock market newsletter editors who are bullish on the market fell to 44.4% from 48.3%, while bearish sentiment rose 2% points to 26.7%. This is a slight decrease in the ratio of bulls to bears, since we’ve been so accustomed to seeing it at 2:1.

To thoroughly confuse those with any leftover conviction, according to Consensus bulls on the stock market are at 74% - a previous high not seen since October 2007. Similarly, 78% are bullish on gold.

Daily Sentiment Indicator
The Daily Sentiment Indicator, calculated by Jake Bernstein, is showing an elevated level of optimism. The 10 day moving average of the DSI is at 70%, having fallen from the recent peak of 75%:
DSI 10 day MA chart compared to SP500 index

Consumer Confidence
The preliminary Reuters/University of Michigan Consumer Confidence index fell to a 3 month low of 66 (from 70.6 in October). Most analysts and economists expected a small increase in confidence. While it was unexpected, it shouldn’t be that surprising since the media has been filled with reports of the unemployment rate hitting the psychologically important 10% level. And as this is a preliminary number, it could be revised later.

consumer sentiment Reuters-Michigan survey Nov 2009

The German ZEW Index
Looking across the pond, the most popular measure of German economic confidence, the ZEW index dropped to 51.1 in November from 56.0. The consensus was expecting 55.0. Meanwhile, the current situation index increased 2 points to -72.2 - with expectations being a rise to -69.

Mutual Fund Cash Positions
Standing on the “shoulder of giants” (aka Jason Goepfert), we looked at the level of cash being held by US equity mutual funds back in September. While being a ’sloppy’ market timing tool, its message was decidedly foreboding. And with the passage of some time, it has become more so as mutual fund managers are holding even less cash:
ICI equity mutual fund cash ratio long term chart

Corporate Insiders
According to Vickers Insider Report, corporate insiders have sharply curtailed their selling. Current buy/sell activity is 1:1.96 - that is on average, insiders are selling 2 shares for each they buy. Since compensation of corporate executives includes a healthy dollop of shares, it is natural for their activity to be skewed. However, since the long term average of the buy/sell ratio is closer to 1:6.5, the current level is rather bullish.

Google Investing Index
Google (GOOD) is a great source for sentiment on the stock market. Google Trends is where the search trends around the world are categorized allowing us a window into the public’s mood. For example, how much people search for “stock market crash” or “buy gold”.

Another metric is the Google Investing Index (GII) which tracks an amalgam of keywords related to investing such as “stock, finance, stocks” and so on. The peak of searches for these keywords was late last year on October 10th 2008 when there was an 86% increase in year over year activity:

google investing index yoy Nov 2009
Source: Google Finance

The opposite happened just recently in mid October 2009 when there was a decrease of 52% in people’s interest in all things related to investing. At least according to this specific measure. If capitulation is defined by total disinterest and apathy then based on the GII, we’ve arrived. This nicely dovetails with the complete withdrawal of US retail mutual fund investors.

Every once in a while I like to check in with a market ‘greybeard’ - my name for someone who has been around enough to see several cycles and has made more correct calls than not. This week, we review Albert Edwards at Societe Generale. He is an avowed bear who completely dismisses any talk of a recovery or bull market.

In a recent research note he flagellates himself for not having seen the ensuing rally off the spring lows:

To be perfectly honest, as the market powered ahead, I, like so many others, waited for the pull-back that never arrived. Do I feel like a grade 1 moron? Yes, I most sincerely do. Should I be beaten mercilessly to within an inch of my miserable life? Definitely.But I remain convinced we are still in a structural bear market and that this economic recovery rests on such shallow foundations that it will be washed away by the first moderate wave.

Always the grump, Edwards expects China to go into a recession, expects a similar fate for the US in 2010 with new lows for the stock market and a deflationary panic is in our future. You can find a recent report from him in the Free Trading Resource (Reports & Articles).

Enjoyed this? Don't miss the next one, grab the feed  or 

                               subscribe through email:  

2 Responses to “Sentiment Overview: Week Of November 13th, 2009”  

  1. 1 primorec

    regarding the insiders:
    “The insider buying & selling data for the week ending November 13th worsened substantially. Total insider selling jumped to over $960MM vs last week’s reading of $729MM. Buying fell to the nearly non-existent level of $29MM”

    How can the data be so different?

  2. 2 Babak

    primorec, the blog you link to is looking only at one side of the equation (sales) and not the ratio of sales/purchases. That explains the difference. You can’t just look at one side for obvious reasons. Having said that, there are varying methods for measuring insider activity and depending on which source you read (Vickers, InsiderScore, etc.) you’ll get slightly different results.

Leave a Reply