The Myth Of Gold As Safehaven
Published July 31st, 2007 in Natural Resources Tags: crash, gold, gold bugs, gold stocks, HUI, safehaven, SPX, stock market crash.
Deep down inside the really hardcore gold bugs want the stock market to crash, gold to go to $3000 (or more) and maybe even have the Fed abolished.
While I do sympathize with their last fantasy, the reality is that even if the stock market does “crash” as they wish, rather than zoom higher, gold and gold stocks will probably fall as well.
I have no idea how this myth was perpetrated but most people believe that gold and gold stocks are the mirror opposite of the stock market. That one loses when the other wins.
Nothing could be further from the truth. History shows that whenever we’ve had a stock market crash, gold has never been a safehaven.
That is to say you would have lost money even if you sold stocks and bought gold ahead of time in anticipation or perfect fore-knowledge of the crash.
Although the recent market swoon is not even approaching “crash” levels, it is a good example of this:
In the chart, the Gold Bugs Index (HUI) is the candlesticks with the axis on the right. And the S&P 500 (SPX) is the line in the chart with the axis on the left.
If you don’t believe me, go back to any stock market crash and see for yourself. And if you’re still a gold bug, it may be time to face reality and accept that our recent gold bull market is over.
crash, gold, gold bugs, gold stocks, HUI, safehaven, SPX, stock market crash
Enjoyed this? Don't miss the next one, grab the feed or
6 Responses to “The Myth Of Gold As Safehaven”
- 1 Pingback on Aug 1st, 2007 at 8:49 am
- 2 Pingback on Aug 16th, 2007 at 5:55 pm
Leave a Reply
Search
Creative Commons License
Trader’s Narrative is powered by
Excellent post, Babak.
Yes, recent advice to buy gold perplexed me because, as you say, I looked at the last several years and gold seemed cyclical (not countercyclical) and up (peaking?), not down now.
Although I agree that gold and gold stock has a positive beta > 0, and therefore follows market direction, I not sure you made the point adequately in the previous post the Gold and Gold stocks are in a Bear market. I don’t think we can make that conclusion just yet. Furthermore calling a top on the k-ratio alone, seems adventurous to me.
Gold is a hedge against inflation, nobody said it was a good investment. As long as inflation is steady, gold will rise, their is no need for a stock market crash.